How Evidence Works in Family Law Cases
In family law cases, evidence plays a central role in helping the court make fair and informed decisions. Whether the issue is about parenting arrangements, property division, or allegations of family violence, the court relies on evidence rather than assumptions or opinions. Understanding what counts as evidence and how it should be presented can make the process clearer and less overwhelming.

What Counts as Evidence?

Evidence in family law can take many forms, depending on the issues before the court.

Common types include:
  • Documents: bank statements, medical records, school reports, text messages, emails, and financial disclosure documents.
  • Affidavits: written statements that set out a person’s version of events, signed and sworn to be true. These are a primary way parties present their evidence.
  • Witness testimony: in some cases, third parties such as teachers, doctors, or family friends may give evidence.
  • Expert reports: for example, property valuations, psychological assessments, or family reports prepared by court-appointed experts.
  • Photographs, recordings, or digital communications: but only if obtained lawfully and relevant to the case.

How Is Evidence Gathered and Presented?

Family law requires full and frank disclosure, particularly in property settlement cases. This means both parties must provide all relevant financial documents, even if they do not favour their position.

Evidence is usually presented through affidavits and supporting documents filed with the court. In some hearings, especially interim or trial hearings, parties may also give oral evidence and be cross-examined.

When expert input is needed, for example, valuing a business or assessing parenting capacity the court may appoint an independent expert, or parties may agree to jointly instruct one.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Many people make mistakes with evidence in family law matters.

Some of the most common pitfalls include:
  • Relying on irrelevant material: The court only considers evidence that directly relates to the issues. Emotional or unnecessary details can weaken a case.
  • Submitting unlawfully obtained recordings: For example, secret recordings of conversations may not be admissible and can cause more harm than good.
  • Not providing full disclosure: Holding back financial information can result in penalties, and may damage credibility.
  • Using affidavits as arguments: An affidavit should be factual, not filled with opinions or speculation.
  • Overloading the court with unnecessary documents: More is not always better; evidence should be clear, concise, and relevant.

Why Evidence Matters

The court’s role is to make decisions that are just, fair, and in the best interests of children where parenting matters are concerned. Reliable, properly presented evidence gives the court the tools to do that. By focusing on relevant facts, parties help ensure their case is heard fairly and efficiently.
For more family law advice like this, feel free to reach out to Genuine Legal for a consultation.
Call us on (07) 2102 0641 if you need our assistance.
Tags:
Related articles
Blog: Serving Divorce Papers in Australia: What You Need to Know
Serving divorce papers in Australia? Understand the service requirements and methods with our expert guidance for seamless proceedings.
Blog: Finances and property: We cannot agree
Navigate financial disputes in Australia with expert legal guidance. Learn about pre-action procedures, duty of disclosure, and time limits for resolution. Schedule a free consultation.
Blog: When mediation fails – what’s next?
Exploring options when mediation fails in family law disputes
Blog: When mediation is not appropriate
Mediation not always ideal for family disputes. Learn when it's ineffective for parenting or property matters, and alternatives when facing urgency or safety issues.