What Happens When Mediation Fails in Family Law?
Family mediation is often the first step for separated couples trying to resolve parenting or property matters. It’s designed to encourage communication, reduce conflict, and avoid going to court. But what happens when mediation doesn’t work? Whether it ends in disagreement or one party refuses to participate, there are still options available to move forward.

1. You Will Receive a Section 60I Certificate

If you’re trying to sort out parenting arrangements and mediation fails, you’ll usually be issued a Section 60I certificate by the accredited Family Dispute Resolution (FDR) practitioner. There are 5 different types of certificates that you could be issued, each one is relevant for specific issues that can arise during mediation.

These certificates confirm that:
  • Both parties attended and tried to resolve the matter, or
  • One party refused or failed to attend, or
  • Mediation was deemed inappropriate due to concerns like family violence or safety.

This certificate is a requirement before you can apply to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, unless your situation qualifies for an exemption (e.g. urgent matters, family violence, or risk to the child).

2. Consider Legal Advice Before Filing

After mediation breaks down, it’s wise to speak with a family lawyer.

They can help you:
  • Understand your legal position
  • Prepare your paperwork properly
  • Advise you on the best next steps, whether that’s applying for parenting or property orders, or considering another pathway to resolution

Proper advice early on can save you time, money, and unnecessary stress down the line.

3. Filing an Application in Court

If no agreement is reached, the next step is filing an application with the Family Court. Depending on the issue, you might be applying for:
  • Parenting Orders: to determine who the child lives with, how much time they spend with each parent, and other key decisions
  • Property Orders: to divide assets, debts, and superannuation
  • Interim Orders: to put temporary arrangements in place while waiting for a final hearing

You’ll need to file the appropriate forms and supporting documents, including the Section 60I certificate if it’s a parenting matter.

4. What Happens in Court?

Once your application is lodged:
  • A first court date will be set. This is often procedural and may lead to interim decisions.
  • The court may order further mediation, reports (e.g. a family report), or expert assessments.
  • If an agreement is still not reached, the matter proceeds to a final hearing, where a judge will make binding decisions based on the best interests of the child or fairness in financial matters.

5. You Can Still Settle at Any Time

Even after mediation fails and court proceedings begin, you can still reach an agreement. In fact, many cases settle before reaching trial. If you do settle, you can apply for Consent Orders to formalise the agreement without needing a judge to decide for you.

When mediation fails, it doesn’t mean all hope is lost, it just means the matter might need more formal steps to be resolved. With the help of a Section 60I certificate, legal guidance, and court processes, you can still find a path forward. The key is to stay focused on solutions that serve the best interests of the children and provide fair outcomes for everyone involved.
For more family law advice like this, feel free to reach out to Genuine Legal for a consultation.
Call us on (07) 2102 0641 if you need our assistance.
Tags:
Related articles
Blog: Serving Divorce Papers in Australia: What You Need to Know
Serving divorce papers in Australia? Understand the service requirements and methods with our expert guidance for seamless proceedings.
Blog: Finances and property: We cannot agree
Navigate financial disputes in Australia with expert legal guidance. Learn about pre-action procedures, duty of disclosure, and time limits for resolution. Schedule a free consultation.
Blog: When mediation fails – what’s next?
Exploring options when mediation fails in family law disputes
Blog: When mediation is not appropriate
Mediation not always ideal for family disputes. Learn when it's ineffective for parenting or property matters, and alternatives when facing urgency or safety issues.